Tournament of errors ends with World Cup elimination for Nigeria's Super Falcons

Nabil Ramdani/BackpagePix/CAF

After nine straight appearances, Nigeria's Super Falcons will not be at the FIFA Women's World Cup in Brazil next year.

It is a sobering come-down for a team that has not only been the most dominant in African women's football for three decades, but has set the standard for the game on the continent.

Goals by Thembi Kgatlana and Refiloe Jane handed South Africa's Banyana Banyana a 2-1 win against the Nigerians, in the play-in game that finally ended the Super Falcons hopes of reaching the World Cup, after a quarterfinal loss to Cameroon denied them a direct path to the Finals.

Nigeria coach Justin Madugu named a different lineup for a fifth straight game, as he struggled to find his best eleven, handing Francisca Ordega her first start of the tournament, and Uchenna Kanu her third. It was unclear what the tactical rationale was, but it barely showed on the pitch and it was South Africa who started the game on the front foot, denying Nigeria possession.

But the Super Falcons took over within the first quarter hour and pushed their rivals back, creating a few chances that saw goalkeeper Kaylin Swart standing stoutly at the Moulay Rachid Stadium. Nigeria's direct play created the first real opportunity of the game, when Michelle Alozie found space inside the box, only to drag her effort just wide of the target.

Despite the efforts of Justin Madugu's side, it was South Africa who struck first, against the run of play in the 56th minute through Thembi Kgatlana. Banyana Banyana doubled their advantage in the 77th minute through captain Refiloe Jane, who latched on to a poorly-defended cornerkick, watching the ball deflect off the leg of substitute Christy Ucheibe to make it 2-0.

With a minute to go, Jane turned villain for her side, handling a goal-bound header from Alozie inside the penalty area. Following a Video Assistant Referee (VAR) review, the referee awarded Nigeria a penalty and issued Jane her second yellow card, reducing South Africa to ten women.

Christy Ucheibe stepped up to convert the spot-kick and cut the deficit to 2-1. But Banyana held on, in the face of relentless Nigeria pressure during stoppage time, preventing the Super Falcons from finding a late equalizer and ending their World Cup hopes.

History made, but of the wrong kind

Losing to South Africa on Thursday meant the Super Falcons plumbed depths they hitherto did not even know existed.

At the last tournament, they made history by becoming the first team to win the continental title a record ten times. This time, they made history too, but of the wrong variety, and in multiple ways.

To start with, the Super Falcons tied for the most games lost by Nigeria at any one tournament, after losing three games in total and also tied with the 2022 team for the third least goals scored at WAFCON ever, with 9. Only the 2008 team (3) and the 2012 team (8) scored less. But tying poor records is the best it got for the ten-time champions. Not only did they concede the most group stage goals (5) of any Falcons team in tournament history, their three goals allowed after the group stage combined to add up to the most goals (8) ever conceded by the team in the tournament.

It gets worse. Finishing outside the top four is their worst ever tournament performance. Never in their history have the Super Falcons failed to make it to the last four.

To add insult to injury, the team that has qualified for every single FIFA Women's World Cup since its inception in 1991, have seen that streak broken.

There was a time when even one of these would have been unthinkable for Africa's most dominant women's national team. Now, it is reality. For all the good they have done previously, this iteration of Super Falcons will have their names etched in infamy for this.

Goalscoring problems cost Nigeria

Speaking of goals...

Over the years, the Super Falcons have had a reputation of scoring goals for fun at WAFCON.

Their bad years at WAFCON have come when they have found goals hard to come by, especially in 2008, when they only managed three goals as they lost their title for the first time. Similarly, when they lost the title in 2012, they only managed eight goals, and nine in 2022.

This year, it was glaring. Despite a host of attacking talent, including six-time African Player of the Year Asisat Oshoala, Rinsola Babajide, Uchenna Kanu, Joy Omewa, Folashade Ijamilusi and Esther Okonkwo, the team found goals hard to come by. This was largely because they failed to fashion clear-cut chances in contrast to the past. And the few that they did create, it was a struggle putting them away. Part of the problem was their predictability, and against South Africa, it was all too glaring. Madugu's tactics did not extend beyond going route one. It worked a peach against Zambia, and for the most part against hapless Egypt. But Cameroon gobbled everything up, and South Africa sussed them out pretty easily, taking advantage of the Super Falcons' lack of creative variety to defend with ease and blunt their attacking threats.

A measly one goal in two knockout games is tied for their worst ever tally in WAFCON history, the other time being in 2008.

And it all came down to how predictable they were, making it easy for Desire Ellis to diffuse any attacks well before it even started.

Tournament of errors come home to roost

In a tournament characterized by errors for the Super Falcons, it was only fitting that they should end it with two more.

First, it was Shukurat Oladipo's wild attempt at a clearance that allowed South Africa to break away and let in Thembi Kgatlana for the first goal. And then a lack of defensive awareness from a cornerkick, meant Nigeria players were all clustered in the box and there was nobody picking up Refiloe Jane on the edge of the box, allowing her to have a free shot at goal. Inevitably, Christy Ucheibe's stuck out foot diverted the ball past Chiamaka Nnadozie for the second goal. A game earlier, it was Jennifer Echegini committing a needless foul to give away the freekick in a dangerous area, while goalkeeper Nnadozie zoned out during the said freekick to allow Myriam Nyadjou a direct line of sight to goal.

In the group phase, Alozie was responsible for giving away a needless penalty kick that led to Egypt's first goal, and the defence going walkabout to allow the second goal.

Defensive and goalkeeping errors also led to three goals against Malawi which started the whole tailspin.

But the errors were not just on the field. Coach Justin Madugu never seemed able to find his best lineup, and kept chopping and changing. His insistence on playing Alozie at left back, despite having two natural left backs in the squad, meant that his full back positions were compromised before a ball was even kicked. That is because Shukurat Oladipo, whom he deployed at right back, is a natural centreback and has none of the instincts of a fullback and Alozie, as a makeshift left back, was wary about joining the attack, and slow to recover when she did. As a result, there was a hesitancy to bomb forward by the fullbacks, depriving the team of much-needed offensive bodies and the attendant threats they would have carried.

Against Cameroon, he inexplicably left Oshoala on the bench until stoppage time, while his decision to leave Christy Ucheibe on the bench against a midfield-dominant and possession-based team like South Africa, was a head scratching puzzle.